These were the kind of moments that help me today, now as some sort of halfway decent horror journalist, understand and hope that a film like Tragedy Girls will have a similar effect. I'm beginning with the younger movie audience here because, this is exactly the kind of movie that would've given me that same feeling, were I 14 going on 15 again. But that's not to say that Tragedy Girls won't be enjoyed by all. It's dark camp, self-awareness, and intelligent sociopathic pair Sadie Cunningham (Brianna Hildebrand) and McKayla Hooper (Alexandra Shipp) have an old school edge to their destruction while feeding the ever starving social media prominence bubble.
The obsession with hashtags and serial killers help propel their online brand when a series of murders plague their middle America town. The interesting fright factor is less the meta- slasher element but more, the commentary hiding in Sadie and McKayla's ability to delight towards a macabre modus operandi for digital stardom. What strengthens this narrative is the relatable bond Shipp and Hildebrand are able to muster for their characters, mimicking our own youth of extreme, emotionally-driven decision making with a equally heavy dose of goal-focused cleverness. High school friendships are commonly shaky because they are often finite. You begin to realize (even if internally fought) you will change and this four year routine will blink by. Writers Chris Lee Hill and Tyler MacIntyre (who also directed) are able to zero in on these vulnerabilities with an injection of smartphone technology. Shipp's McKayla stands out as the entitled smartass who, for all of her arrogance, has a sympathetic peel to her mischievous persona. Hildebrand's Sadie fiddling with the social stratum of their small town life that makes the third act of the story delightfully unpredictable.
An overall fun series of frames, more glam than goth, with bright visual choices and wicked killing spree masks that I actually want for my own Halloween costume, Tragedy Girls manages to unabashedly pay homage to the films the older crowd will be comparing it to without stripping away its original flare and attraction for teenagers currently unable to look up from their phones for five minutes. Certainly for Tragedy Girls, they will.